7 Reese's Book Club Picks From May to November 2026

I’ve kept these seven Reese’s Book Club picks in month order, from May to November 2026. The stories range from an art-world murder to women making history, a mysterious connection to the sea and a family watched over by ghosts.

By Leon Bossasi · Updated November 17, 2026

The choices

The May to November 2026 selections

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Cover of The Fine Art of Lying by Alexandra Andrews

01

The Fine Art of Lying

A woman trying to find her place in Manhattan’s art world gets caught between a stolen painting and a murder investigation.

See more

Clare Bast has married into a wealthy Upper East Side life, but she has left an art-history dissertation unfinished and still feels out of place. A new social circle gives her a way back into the work she cares about. Then a painting connected to her research turns up in a dealer’s home, and an opportunity becomes a very dangerous connection.

The May pick puts ambition and belonging inside a crime story. Clare’s knowledge of art brings her closer to a world she wants to enter, even as the investigation makes those connections look incriminating. The suspense has as much to do with whom she trusts as with who has the painting.

Reese’s Book Club’s May 2026 selection

Cover of A Pair of Aces by Marie Benedict and Victoria Christopher Murray

02

A Pair of Aces

A prosecutor and a brothel owner form an unlikely alliance against Lucky Luciano in 1930s New York.

See more

Eunice Carter, Manhattan’s first Black female prosecutor, sees a route into Luciano’s organization through its involvement in prostitution. Polly Adler knows the people who could help build that case, but her business and its workers are exposed to the mob’s power. Cooperation means risking lives as well as careers.

June’s selection approaches a familiar gangster story through two women with very different kinds of access. One works inside the legal system and the other knows what it leaves out. Their alliance gives the historical fiction a practical question to follow: how do you turn what people know into evidence they can safely give?

Browse more historical-fiction reviews

Reese’s Book Club’s June 2026 selection

Cover of A Founding Mother by Stephanie Dray and Laura Kamoie

03

A Founding Mother

Abigail Adams builds her own independence while raising a family through revolution and advising the man helping to shape a new country.

See more

With John Adams away for long periods, Abigail manages their farm, makes investments and keeps their household going through war, illness and loss. As the family’s political life expands, she moves from revolutionary Boston into diplomacy abroad and the social world of the new American republic.

July’s pick follows the work behind the public history. Domestic responsibilities, money and the opportunities available to women are part of Abigail’s political life throughout the novel. It is a fictional portrait of a historical person, with a much broader span than the investigation at the center of A Pair of Aces.

Reese’s Book Club’s July 2026 selection

Cover of The Wild Beneath by Kelly Anderson

04

The Wild Beneath

After a tsunami, Annie MacLeod is pulled between her life on land and a stranger whose connection to the sea she cannot explain.

See more

Annie grew up aboard a sailboat in the Pacific Northwest. In the aftermath of the disaster, she rescues Walker, a man who does not speak but makes a sound only she can hear. Her childhood companion Evan offers a future on land, while Walker draws her toward an unfamiliar world beneath the water.

The August selection brings a love story into contact with the fantastic. Grief and Annie’s attachment to the ocean shape the choice between these two lives. The story also returns to her six years later, when a sound she thought she had left behind reaches her again.

Reese’s Book Club’s August 2026 selection

Cover of Big Little Truths by Liane Moriarty

05

Big Little Truths

The Big Little Lies families return ten years later, with teenage children and a new threat at school. Read Big Little Lies first.

See more

Madeline, Celeste, Jane, Renata and Bonnie are dealing with a different stage of family life. Their children are in high school, and the adults have problems they have kept from one another and from their kids. When a severed finger arrives in the principal’s mail, everyday worries become part of a much more unsettling picture.

September’s pick revisits relationships and consequences established in Big Little Lies. I’d begin with that novel before coming here. The new mystery sits alongside questions about marriage, parenting and how much of a family’s past its children should know.

Reese’s Book Club’s September 2026 selection

Cover of Sophie, Standing There by Meg Mason

06

Sophie, Standing There

Cut off from the people she loves, a book-festival worker starts relying on the company of a novelist she has never met.

See more

Sophie Pattison once had a job she enjoyed, a close friend, a husband and a brother she could turn to. Now she lives alone, avoids her family and is in danger of losing her work. Rediscovering a writer she loved in her twenties gives her something to hold on to, until she begins imagining what it would mean to meet that writer.

October’s selection stays close to loneliness and the strange intimacy of reading. A voice on the page can feel like a companion even when the person behind it knows nothing about you. Mason explores that attachment through uncomfortable humor, heartache and Sophie’s wish to reconnect.

Reese’s Book Club’s October 2026 selection

Cover of The Great Wherever by Shannon Sanders

07

The Great Wherever

A woman inherits part of a Tennessee farm, where her plans to escape debt meet family history and some very opinionated ghosts.

See more

After losing her father, Aubrey Lamb learns that he has left her a share of land she barely knows. A possible sale could help with her debts, but it also draws her into the lives of relatives with their own claims on the place. The dead are watching, with plenty to say about what the living should do next.

November’s pick uses the ghosts to widen a family story across generations. The farm is both something with a price and a place where people have built their lives. Aubrey’s immediate need for a way forward meets the memories, disagreements and expectations that come with belonging to the Lamb family.

Reese’s Book Club’s November 2026 selection

How these picks differ

The historical novels follow women whose work cuts across the public events around them. The contemporary suspense turns on money, reputation and family secrets. The more fantastic stories let the sea or the dead become part of everyday life, while Sophie’s story stays close to loneliness and a reader’s attachment to a writer. You can enter the list wherever that sounds interesting, with one reading-order note: Big Little Truths continues Big Little Lies.

Quick answers

Questions readers ask before buying

Should I read Big Little Lies before Big Little Truths?

Yes. Big Little Truths returns to the same women ten years later, when their children are teenagers. Starting with Big Little Lies gives you the history of their relationships and the events the sequel builds on.

Are these seven Reese's Book Club picks all thrillers?

The selection spans several genres. There is art-world suspense, historical fiction, a love story with fantastical elements, domestic mystery, contemporary fiction about loneliness and a family saga with ghosts.

Share this guidePass it along to another reader.

Sources for this guide

Sources & references